
Grand Theft Auto IV review: where cover shooter, social pastiche and bowling sim meet
Continuing our series of GTA retrospectives, we look at the one that laid the foundations for GTA Online
This was the moment Grand Theft Auto became what it is today. Before its release in 2008, the franchise meant silly, irreverent hijinks in an open world, with just enough violence to furrow the brows of parents and tabloid writers. But with Grand Theft Auto IV, Rockstar turned it into a life sim, an interactive social commentary, and a hangout space for you and your mates.
Which is quite an accomplishment, for a game that also has a substantial narrative layer about two Eastern European cousins trying to make their way in a grimy American east coast metropolis. It’s cinematic and referential to pop culture, but also has moments of genuine pathos. Niko Bellic isn’t just a Tony Montana stand-in with a shaved head and a dirty tracksuit – Rockstar gave this protagonist emotions, if you squint hard enough through the blood splatter.
It goes like this. Upon hearing about how well his cousin Roman is doing after leaving their home country for Liberty City, Niko Bellic boards the cargo ship Platypus to escape his criminal past and chase the American Dream. After the most memorable airport pickup in gaming history, Niko quickly realises his cuz has been dressing up the reality of his life a bit. Far from the comfort and excess described in his letters, Roman lives in a run-down apartment, drives a cab and is in debt to loan sharks. On the other hand, he lives really near a bowling alley.
What follows is a fresh take on what had erstwhile been the GTA formula of linear missions in an open world you get to cause havoc in outside of them. This time those linear missions are joined by optional activities and social hangouts, stuff that makes Liberty City feel richer and more alive.
The phone calls from Roman became meme fodder circa 2008, because a certain type of player hated them. They just wanted to progress the story and shoot people, but instead their phone was constantly going off with invitations to take girls on dates or go bowling. Woe is me.
GTA IV leaned even harder into the idea of Liberty City being a social hangout space by introducing a 32-player online mode, laying the foundations for the GTA Online we know and love today. Only, instead of buying million dollar apartments and pulling off daring heists, it was more ‘look how far this playground equipment shoots this motorbike into the sky if you catch it right'. Simpler times.
There are mechanical improvements evident here that bring the experience closer to modern day GTA, like the introduction of a cover system. Niko’s mobile phone becomes a hub for numerous interaction types, as it did in later releases, and the city’s public transport network is useable, allowing Niko to hop on and off at subway stops. But it wasn’t really the nuts and bolts of gameplay that elevated this game, as much as the feeling of being in Liberty City.
Once again it used radio stations to parody contemporary culture, but took it further this time, into TV shows, theatre performances and overheard conversations on the street. It has a knack of making you feel like Niko must be feeling – an interloper in a strange, loud, hyperconsumerist place where everyone’s in a hurry.
And it sticks the landing of Niko’s character arc, too. He arrives looking for a fresh start, away from the violence and corruption he encountered at home. But he soon discovers that all the wealth and opulence in Liberty City is built on exactly the same bloodshed and lawbreaking he thought he’d escaped. Faced with that grim truth, Niko decides to give into nihilism and criminality to make his way in the world. This is all really just frosting on the cake that’s supposed to explain why you’re robbing and shooting so much, it didn’t need to be that thoughtful.
GTA V would hit similar themes, but Niko’s story truly blindsided gamers in 2008 and represented a coming of age moment for the series’ writing. If you ask us, it’s worth screening a few phone calls and going to a few bowling nights for that.
Top Gear
Newsletter
Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.






